data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/51ac7/51ac774eef8334e5ea8ee695e589dd360c5d89a1" alt=""
"As a rule, I'm not a big fan of comedy and novelty songs..."
I'm always curious what a line like this means since everyone has a different opinion. What does "As a rule, I'm not a big fan..." mean? What rule? Who set this rule? Is there some rule out there I'm not aware of that says that people aren't to like humorous recordings or some rule that people aren't to admit they like comedy songs?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c821b/c821b8a3eedd34a7795fc55e204b927cf997bf46" alt=""
Also, there's this urban legend that people "stoop to comedy singing" if they have less than stellar singing voices. This can be true...but in Ray Stevens' case it's the opposite. Ray is known as a comedy singer and his comical music videos reinforce that reputation but let's not forget the numerous love ballads and legitimate serious recordings he's written and or performed during the last 50 some years. Roger Miller comes to mind as being on par with Ray when it comes to mixing the silly, goofy, and satirical and the seriousness of other topics that come with relationships.
Moving on...
I think puns are witty and creative by the way. Also, there's nothing to be ashamed of in liking "Grandma Got Run Over By a Reindeer" while at the same time liking the more serious Christmas songs of Bing Crosby, for example. I can tolerate both extremes so I'm an example of someone that can easily listen to an album of Bing Crosby and if I choose to I can listen to an album of nutty novelty songs all in the same day. Some feel they have to only like or appreciate one thing or one music style and nothing else...to some extent this is okay because there are some very bad and horrific material routinely exposed to children who in return grow up with a sensitivity and, gasp, an actual appreciation for rappers who glorify beating their wives or girlfriends and these aimless and hopeless kids think wearing 40 tons of jewelery and speaking in half-sentences is the epitome of being cool. In that scenario I'm all for parents steering their children clear of that stuff...but that's an entirely different argument for a different day.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/01e13/01e13db3c9b6e064c918d93b13ebf0a17b687234" alt=""
So, what makes the novelty song? In my opinion you need to have a subject matter that's either currently popular or something that the public at large is familiar with and there needs to be an underlying tone of humor within the song. The subject matter could be anything from a remote control to a car. I think reality shows are one of the biggest scams in generating viewers but you'd be surprised by how serious people take those kinds of shows and how wrapped up people get watching so and so being kicked out of a house or off an island or off a talent show. This is why, I feel, comedians today when and if they attack reality shows, they don't get a mainstream outlet because the mainstream takes those shows seriously.
The same is true for music...when it comes to the public perception of what's serious and what's not. When a song strays from what is considered normal then it's given the novelty moniker even though there perhaps wouldn't be anything "funny" within the entire song...just the odd or strange production value would give it a novelty tag. This is why I said if it were 1950 nearly everything on Top-40 pop radio now would be deemed a novelty song because everything sounds bizarre but yet if you played nothing but 1950 pop music on the radio now the music listeners would consider those songs bizarre and strange by comparison.
Glancing at the Hot 100 now you'll see people and groups by the names of Black Eyed Peas, Kesha, Lady Gaga, Jay Z, Snoop Dog, Akon, and others. Now, 95% of those acts put on a "show"...at least I assume they do. It's much like wrestling...where everyone knows it's fake but people who watch are still drawn into it. I put Top-40 pop music of today and the last 20+ years into that same category. The acts put on a show, some critics say a freak show, and yet the music buyers eat it up. Some consumers I think actually believe in all the staged hysterics and goings-on when it comes to rock and pop personalities of today. The stupidity and antics that take place today in pop and rock music is heralded as awesome and cool by those who are taken in by the theatrics and the overt showiness of it.
AC honestly you are a wonder, you are so informative about the good Doctor Ray Stevens, if it weren't for him and the pleasure he gives us with laughter, wit and wisdom the world would be missing out on a great not only entertainer but a wonderful human being.
ReplyDeletelinda